What are Lemmy’s feelings about the best cloud storage options these days, if you really want to break into the 1-2TB range? I’m not there yet, probably not even halfway there, but I like the peace of mind of potentially having the space if I need it. And I think subscribing to something in the Netflix price range is maybe something I’m ready for.

My thoughts so far:

pcloud - Intriguing because you can pay for a “lifetime” plan of 2TB of storage. But it’s $350, which is a lot, and I don’t know that I love the interface or usability, and I don’t know if I trust them.

iDrive - Super affordable. 5tb for “just” $80/year. It might be the best deal, but nothing about their identity suggests to me that they are “good guys.” By which I mean, I’m not sure I trust them to make long-term promises for any specific plan.

Mega - I like its very anti-google, very encrypted attitude. Born from the ashes of megaupload, they built encryption and zero knowledge into it. I LOVE that you can connect to it through the android app Solid Explorer and therefore don’t even need the mega app if you don’t want it. I hear bad things about it though? And it’s pretty expensive at $115 per year for 2TB.

My personal thoughts/reasoning/caveats:

Homebrew stuff: I don’t quite trust myself to use a homebrew setup like Nextcloud or Syncthing correctly. There’s too much in terms of labor, upkeep, catastrophic single points of failure where you could lose everything. I feel like I’m 70% of the way to being smart enough to do this.

Avoiding the Bad Guys and the Free Stuff: I’ve tried the free version of just about everything, from Google to Onedrive to Dropbox to Mediafire to Mega. There’s even an android app that offers 1 free terrabyte?? But I don’t want something from the bad guys where I’m going to be integrated into their closed source death drap: Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Apple, and I don’t want a too-good-to-be-true free service where I’m the product.

I also would prefer to avoid something from the upstarts who kinda-sorta imitate the bad guys: Dropbox, Mediafire, Box. Because I’m not sure how much I can trust any specific long term promise from them.

It sounds like you’re saying nothing is good enough! What exactly do you want!? Something from good guys, not bad guys. Something like Standardnotes, but for file storage. They emphasize privacy, good governance principles and longevity of their service. Or Linode, with their independence, sense of mission, love of Linux & free software, all of which tells me they are good guys.

Probably the correct answer is (1) here’s this magical perfect source I never thought of, or (2) I’m thinking this much about it, I should probably do Nextcloud or syncthing given all the constraints that I’m putting out there.

Anyway, that’s my thoughts on cloud storage. What are yours?

  • Azure
    2•2 years ago

    ‘Cloud Storage’ is a bit underspecified. What are your use-cases, specifically?

    Linode actually has a ‘cloud storage’ offering based on the Free ‘ceph’ distributed storage system’s implementation of S3.

    I’m personally very fond of rsync.net, which you can access via scp/sftp.

    • @abbenm@lemmy.mlOP
      1•2 years ago

      My use case primarily is real time copying of photos and videos from my phone, and secondarily just any other files. And I’m thinking of something along the lines of Google drive or Dropbox or mega. Accessing via sFTP is awesome, and a huge amount of flexibility. I did not even realistically hope that any option would have that.

      • @electric_nan@lemmy.ml
        1•2 years ago

        Nextcloud has an ‘auto upload’ feature on the android client (idk about ios). You can set any number of local folders to upload any new files to your server. You can have it upload over mobile data, wifi, or both.

      • @toneverends@lemmy.ml
        1•2 years ago

        Syncthing really seems to just work though. Slightly complicated to set up but only because it’s clear what it’s doing and there’s a lot of options to set juuuust right for each use case you can imagine. I mostly use it for syncing photo/music folders between linux desktop and android phone, and to have shared folders with friends and colleagues.

        Not really for keeping sensitive data on untrusted servers, but there are efforts to enable encrypted storage on untrusted-devices: https://docs.syncthing.net/users/untrusted.html

        Syncthing for syncing/sharing and encrypted borg backups out to rsync.net or own/friends NAS boxes for archiving.